The Right Reverend Ruth Woodliff-Stanley has called the Rev. Courtney Davis-Shoemaker as priest-in-charge of St. Peter’s, Charleston, a church that was returned to our diocese last year and was most recently known as The Church of the Good Shepherd. Ordained to the priesthood in 2009, the Rev. Davis-Shoemaker has served for the past five years as assistant priest of St. Stephen’s, Charleston. She will begin this full-time role at St. Peter’s on November 1, 2024.  As Rev. Davis-Shoemaker explores the possibilities for ministry at this location over the coming months, it is expected that the church, located at 1393 Miles Drive in West Ashley, will reopen in early 2025.

“I could not be more thrilled that the Rev. Courtney Davis-Shoemaker has accepted the call to serve as priest-in-charge of St. Peter’s,” said Bishop Woodliff-Stanley. “Her deep spirituality and her gifts in convening community, administration, and pastoral care, will help set St. Peter’s on a firm foundation. Additionally, both her experience in renewing church communities and her creativity will inform the early days of developing a new season in this historic parish that will serve the needs of the neighborhood and the wider community.”

Over the past few months, Bishop Woodliff-Stanley has convened several conversations with members of the West Ashley community as they imagined together the future of the church. The Rev. Davis-Shoemaker took part in some of these conversations, and she plans to continue these conversations and build on that early discernment when she begins on November 1 and prepares to reopen in the new year. “This period will also involve intentional listening to neighbors and interested parties to creatively think about ministry in West Ashley and how we can best support our community,” said Davis-Shoemaker.

The Rev. Davis-Shoemaker looks forward to creatively moving the church forward. As she noted in a message to the congregation at St. Stephen’s, Charleston, “With Bishop Woodliff- Stanley’s support, I will explore alternative times for worship and how we may best engage non-churchgoers and Episcopalians who may have left the church after the schism,” said Davis-Shoemaker. “This will be a time to experiment in how we spread the message of God’s unending love and invite people to bring their authentic selves into a new community. I do not know exactly how God will use this new space and what will come but I am excited to prayerfully explore what God may be up to in West Ashley!”

While the church building in West Ashley was constructed in the 1970s and the name eventually changed from St. Peter’s to the Church of the Good Shepherd, the origins of the congregation date back to its initial location as St. Peter’s Episcopal Church on Logan Street in downtown Charleston. That building was destroyed by fire in 1861, but the cemetery remains to this day. In 1927, the congregation reorganized and merged with Christ Church on Rutledge Avenue to form a new St. Peter’s on that site. It moved to West Ashley in 1973. As our diocese looks to reopen the church, it will return to the historic name of St. Peter’s Episcopal Church.

A native of Asheville, North Carolina, Davis-Shoemaker graduated from The General Theological Seminary in 2008 and was ordained a priest the following year in the Diocese of Massachusetts. She has served as the urban resident at St. Stephen's in Lynn, MA; a vicar at St. Andrew's Episcopal Church in Haw River, NC; Episcopal/ Lutheran chaplain at Elon University; and most recently as the assistant priest at St. Stephen's, Charleston. Having moved to Charleston in 2017 with her spouse, the Rev. Adam Shoemaker, she has also served on the Standing Committee and Commission on Ministry in the Diocese of South Carolina. Courtney and Adam have three children and their family moved to West Ashley in June 2024.

View the announcement from St. Stephen’s, Charleston, at this link.

St. James, Charleston, located at 1872 Camp Road on James Island, a parish with roots in The Episcopal Church dating back more than 200 years, returned to the Diocese of South Carolina and The Episcopal Church on Thursday, December 1, 2022, as a result of the South Carolina Supreme Court’s August ruling. In that decision, the Court determined that St. James, Charleston, and seven other churches that left The Episcopal Church in 2012 and later joined the Anglican Church in North America (ACNA), did not have proper ownership based on state trust law. The Right Reverend Ruth Woodliff-Stanley, bishop of the Diocese of South Carolina, has called the Reveverend Taylor Smith to lead the church as priest-in-charge, and he will lead the service of Holy Eucharist to reopen St. James Episcopal Church on Sunday, December 4, at 10 am. Going forward, services of Holy Eucharist will be held each Sunday at 8 am and 10 am.

Bishop Woodliff-Stanley is hopeful for the future of St. James, and for the pastoral skills and experience the Rev. Smith will bring to the congregation. “I am thrilled to call the Rev. Taylor Smith to serve as priest-in-charge of St. James as we welcome this historic church back to the diocese,” said Bishop Woodliff-Stanley. “Taylor is a seasoned priest with a heart for outreach and a keen pastoral intuition; his easy manner and gracious spirit will be great gifts in helping us reestablish St. James as a strong presence in our diocese.”

A lifelong Episcopalian, Fr. Taylor has roots in Buffalo, NY, and spent his high school years in New Jersey before moving to North Carolina to attend Duke University as an undergraduate. Upon graduation, he began a career as a commercial loan officer near Charlotte for about six years prior to discerning a call to the priesthood. He graduated from Virginia Theological Seminary in 1996 and was ordained to the priesthood in the Diocese of Western North Carolina where he continued to serve in diocesan and parish ministry for four years. In 2000, he was called to the Diocese of Maryland, where he served at Grace Church, Elkridge for 12 years and then St. Mark’s Church in Highland, MD for nine years. In January, Fr. Taylor moved to Charleston with his wife, Kathy, after she accepted a new job.

Since moving here earlier this year, Fr. Taylor has spent time visiting a number of Episcopal churches in the Lowcountry as he discerned his next call. He shares Bishop Woodliff-Stanley’s vision for the future of St. James Episcopal Church on James Island. “I am equally honored and excited to be called by Bishop Woodliff-Stanley to serve St. James,” said Fr. Taylor. “I look forward to living into the call and living up to the challenge.  As with everywhere else in the world, there’s great opportunity in James Island to spread Good News of God's inclusive love and we will do that through worship and by serving Christ by serving the world around us.”       

​After nearly 10 years of litigation instigated by the churches that wanted to leave The Episcopal Church, the South Carolina Supreme Court determined that eight of the 36 churches which had claimed possession of their properties and left The Episcopal Church, including St. James in Charleston, had created an irrevocable trust in favor of The Episcopal Church and its associated diocese, The (Episcopal) Diocese of South Carolina. St. James, Charleston, located on James Island, is the sixth church to be returned to the historic diocese since the Court published decisions in April and August of this year.

St. James Church originated from the Saint Andrew’s Parish that was created when the South Carolina General Assembly passed the Church Act of 1706, and by 1720, St. James Church was active on James Island.  The Diocese of South Carolina was one of the nine original dioceses that formed The Episcopal Church after the American Revolution, and St. James, Charleston, was a part of the diocese for centuries prior to the diocesan schism in 2012. The church is located on James Island at 1872 Camp Road. 

Over the past week, St. Bartholomew's Episcopal Church in Hartsville was returned to our historic diocese and The Episcopal Church. Founded in 1902, the church is located right alongside Coker College at 103 Campus Avenue. It was previously announced that Bishop Ruth Woodliff-Stanley has called the Rev. Michael Bye as interim priest-in-charge of this congregation. He is also currently serving as the same at nearby St. David's, Cheraw. All are welcome to attend the reopening of St. Bart's this Sunday at 9:30 am. 

​The church also plans to livestream the service on their new Facebook page at this link. Check out their new website at: www.stbartsepiscopal-hartsville.org. Please keep this congregation in your prayers during this transition.

Decisions by the South Carolina Supreme Court in April and August of this year initiated the return of at least seven churches, as well as diocesan property and the St. Christopher Camp and Conference Center on Seabrook Island. Below is an update on each of the transitions.

The return of each church requires a tremendous amount of transitional work and negotiation, and since the Orders of the Court, the following churches have returned to the Episcopal Diocese of South Carolina: St. John’s, Johns Island (July 2022); St. David’s, Cheraw (August 2022); Christ Church, Mt. Pleasant (September 2022); and Holy Trinity, Charleston (September 2022). Episcopal worship services have resumed at each church, with the exception of Holy Trinity, where diocesan leadership is still in discernment about the best path forward. The Acorn School continues to operate at Holy Trinity and the diocesan office is working with the school’s leadership.

St. Bartholomew’s in Hartsville was scheduled to return at the end of September, but the date of transition has been moved to the end of October to accommodate the departing members of the ACNA congregation and their rector. Due to unforeseen circumstances that resulted in a delay in the ACNA congregation moving to their new worship space, the Episcopal congregation at St. Bartholomew’s graciously allowed them to remain for one more month. St. Bartholomew’s Episcopal Church is scheduled to reopen on Sunday, October 30. The Rev. Michael Bye, interim priest-in-charge at St. David’s, Cheraw, will be serving St. Bartholomew’s as well, as the diocese continues to search for permanent leadership.

Of the remaining returning congregations, St. James, Charleston is expected to reopen next, with an anticipated date of All Saints Sunday, November 6, 2022, under the leadership of the Rev. Taylor M. Smith. Discernment is in process regarding how best to serve Episcopalians in and surrounding Fort Motte and the best use of returning property there. The diocese is awaiting a further decision of the Court regarding Good Shepherd, Charleston, as well as Old St. Andrew’s, Charleston, and Holy Cross, Stateburg. 

Details on a settlement between our diocese and the ACNA diocese regarding diocesan properties were announced by Bishop Ruth Woodliff-Stanley on September 27, 2022. Since that time, St. Christopher Camp and Conference Center was returned to the Episcopal Diocese of South Carolina on October 1, 2022, led by seasoned Episcopal Camp and Conference Center executive directors, the Rev. Deacon Helen and Rick Hargreaves. All staff except for the most recent executive director have been asked to continue their employment, and they have been most helpful as we continue through this transition. The camp and conference center, and barrier island programs, continue operating without interruption.

Bishop Woodliff-Stanley has named a strategic Steering Committee, led by the Rev. Laura Rezac, that will report to the bishop and the Trustees regarding the operation of St. Christopher Camp and Conference Center. In addition, the bishop, with the support of the Trustees, has engaged Rob Watson and Stuart Campbell, veteran executive directors and consultants from Episcopal Camps & Conference Center ECCC Ministries, to help the bishop, the bishop’s steering committee, and St. Christopher’s interim executive directors frame the scope of work at the camp and conference center for the coming months.
​
“While these transitional issues have been taking much of the focus lately, I am thrilled about what the Spirit is doing across our diocese, among all of the congregations of our historic diocese,” said Bishop Woodliff-Stanley. “The returning congregations are a part of this emerging vision, and I am excited for us all to embark on this next season of ministry in the Episcopal Diocese of South Carolina. I can’t wait for the people of the diocese to learn more at our Diocesan Convention next month.”

The Right Reverend Ruth Woodliff-Stanley has called the Rev. Taylor M. Smith as priest-in-charge of St. James Episcopal Church in Charleston (James Island), which will soon be returning to the Diocese of South Carolina and The Episcopal Church as a result of the SC Supreme Court decision in April 2022.  Fr. Taylor, who recently served a congregation in the Diocese of Maryland, will lead the reopening of St. James Episcopal Church on Sunday, November 6.

Bishop Woodliff-Stanley is hopeful for the future of St. James, and for the pastoral skills and experience Fr. Taylor will bring to the congregation. “I am thrilled to call the Rev. Taylor Smith to serve as priest-in-charge of St. James as we welcome this historic church back to the diocese,” said Bishop Woodliff-Stanley. “Taylor is a seasoned priest with a heart for outreach and a keen pastoral intuition; his easy manner and gracious spirit will be great gifts in helping us reestablish St. James as a strong presence in our diocese.”

A lifelong Episcopalian, Fr. Taylor has roots in Buffalo, NY, and spent his high school years in New Jersey before moving to North Carolina to attend Duke University as an undergraduate. Upon graduation, he began a career as a commercial loan officer near Charlotte for about six years prior to discerning a call to the priesthood. He graduated from Virginia Theological Seminary in 1996 and was ordained to the priesthood in the Diocese of Western North Carolina where he continued to serve in diocesan and parish ministry for four years.

In 2000, he was called to the Diocese of Maryland, where he served at Grace Church, Elkridge for 12 years and then St. Mark’s Church in Highland, MD for nine years. In January, Fr. Taylor moved to Charleston with his wife, Kathy, after she accepted a job with Roper St. Francis Healthcare.

Since moving here earlier this year, Fr. Taylor has spent time visiting a number of Episcopal churches in the Lowcountry as he discerned his next call. He shares Bishop Woodliff-Stanley’s vision for the future of St. James Episcopal Church on James Island. “I am equally honored and excited to be called by Bishop Woodliff-Stanley to serve St. James,” said Fr. Taylor. “I look forward to living into the call and living up to the challenge.  As with everywhere else in the world, there’s great opportunity in James Island to spread Good News of God's inclusive love and we will do that through worship and by serving Christ by serving the world around us.”

​While Fr. Taylor and his wife are new residents of South Carolina, Kathy was born in Columbia, SC, and much of her extended family still lives in the area. Married for 26 years, they have two sons: Stafford, a senior at the University of South Carolina, and Mason, who works in the Charleston area.
​
Details and service times for Fr. Taylor’s first Sunday at St. James are still being finalized, and will be shared as soon as they are available. With a history dating back to the early 1700s, St. James was a part of St. Andrew’s Parish and has a long history with the Episcopal Diocese of South Carolina. It is located directly across from the Bishop Gadsden Episcopal Retirement Community at 1872 Camp Road in Charleston (James Island). 

In response to the South Carolina Supreme Court’s opinion published on August 17, the historic Episcopal Diocese of South Carolina filed a Petition for Rehearing and a Motion for Relief from Judgment on Thursday, September 1, in regard to the court’s recent decisions concerning two churches that were once part of the historic diocese—Old St. Andrew’s in Charleston, and The Church of the Holy Cross in Stateburg.

In the Petition for Rehearing, attorneys for the Episcopal Diocese of South Carolina note that while the Court made a “factual determination and issued a declaratory judgment” as to whether the two churches revoked the trusts they expressly created, no court “previously addressed whether these parish trusts were revocable or actually revoked based on post-2006 evidence” because it was not previously considered an issue in the case. Because it was not considered, the Episcopal Diocese did not have “reason or opportunity to introduce evidence on this issue.” The petition requests that the Court reverse or vacate the rulings on revocability or revocation involving these two churches, or allow for the introduction of additional evidence before making a final ruling.

In the Motion for Relief from Judgment, various evidence was presented to support a cause for relief from the declaratory judgement in favor of Old St Andrew’s, Charleston, and Holy Cross, Stateburg, based on the fact that the trusts were not revocable or that our diocese should be allowed to present further evidence to the Court. The motion also notes that a lack of full transparency between legal counsel on some issues constituted what is legally known as a “fraud on the court” that would be sufficient to provide relief from judgment.

Bishop Ruth Woodliff-Stanley expressed her gratitude in this moment. “I am grateful to our chancellor and legal team for their hard work and wisdom, and pray for the Court to respond with justice and clarity that will allow us to move to full resolution of these matters,” said Bishop Woodliff-Stanley. “This represents another step on what has been a long and trying journey, but even in this moment, God is unfolding a new season before us. I look forward to discovering with you all that God has in store.”

Once the Court has published the filings on their site, they will be linked here. Until then, a copy of the Petition for Rehearing can be viewed at this link , and the Motion for Relief from Judgment can be viewed at this link. All additional exhibits will be available when shared on the Court’s website.